MORGANTOWN, West Virginia — At some point, enough has to be enough. West Virginia’s defense has gone from concerning to downright disastrous over the last two weeks, and after another ugly performance against Iowa State, you have to wonder how much longer Rich Rodriguez is willing to watch this continue before making some kind of significant change.

The Mountaineers gave up 609 yards against Oklahoma State. That was supposed to be the wake-up call. It was supposed to be the kind of embarrassing defensive performance that gets everyone’s attention and leads to a much different effort the following week. Instead, West Virginia went to Ames and gave up another 577 yards. That’s 1,186 yards of offense allowed in two games. You simply cannot win consistently in the Big 12 playing defense like that.

And Rich Rodriguez knows it. After the Iowa State loss, Rodriguez didn’t try to sugarcoat what happened. He called the defense “atrocious,” talked about how undisciplined his team was and admitted that West Virginia wasn’t coached well enough to win the game. Those are strong words from a head coach, and I don’t think they should be ignored. So now the obvious question becomes: Has Rodriguez seen enough?

Defensive coordinator Zac Alley is going to take the majority of the heat. That’s just how this works. When you’re the defensive coordinator and your unit gives up more than 1,100 yards in two games, people are going to start calling for your job. But I still don’t believe this is as simple as saying Zac Alley suddenly forgot how to coach defense.

I’ve said it before and I’ll continue to say it: West Virginia has a personnel problem on that side of the football. The Mountaineers simply didn’t invest enough in proven defensive talent through the transfer portal, particularly compared to what was done offensively. You can have the greatest scheme in the world, but eventually your players have to win one-on-one matchups, get off blocks, cover receivers and make tackles. Right now, West Virginia isn’t doing those things nearly well enough.

That doesn’t mean Alley gets a free pass, either. When the defense is this bad, everybody has to be evaluated. Scheme, play calling, position coaches, personnel, practice, tackling and communication all have to be looked at. That ultimately falls on Rodriguez. What makes the situation even more frustrating is that this West Virginia offense appears capable of winning football games. Michael Hawkins Jr. gives the Mountaineers a dynamic quarterback, and WVU just scored 42 points on the road against Iowa State. In most weeks, scoring 42 points should be enough to win. It wasn’t.

That’s why I don’t think Rodriguez can simply allow this to continue and hope things eventually get better. Does that mean Zac Alley gets fired this week? I would be surprised if that happened. We’re still only five games into the season, and making a coordinator change in the middle of the year is a major decision. But something has to change.

Maybe Rodriguez becomes more involved with the defense. Maybe responsibilities on the defensive staff are adjusted. Maybe younger players get opportunities. Maybe the scheme gets simplified. Maybe WVU becomes much more aggressive about finding combinations that actually work. Whatever the answer is, doing the same thing and expecting different results isn’t an option anymore.

West Virginia started this season 3-0. There was legitimate excitement surrounding this team after the win over Virginia. Two games later, the Mountaineers are 3-2, 0-2 in the Big 12, and suddenly facing a critical home game against Arizona. Lose that one, and WVU is 3-3 with three consecutive losses and an 0-3 conference record. That’s when the conversation surrounding this team changes completely.

Rodriguez has spent a lot of time talking about building a hard edge at West Virginia. Toughness, discipline, physicality and accountability have been at the center of what he wants this program to become. Now we’re going to find out what accountability actually looks like, because when your defense gives up 1,186 yards in two games, something has to change. The only question is how big that change will be.

Share: