PROVO, Utah — West Virginia’s trip to Provo was supposed to be a chance to show progress under Rich Rodriguez. Instead, it turned into another reminder of just how far this team has to go. The Mountaineers were manhandled by No. 23 BYU, falling 38–24 and dropping to 2-4 overall, 0-3 in the Big 12.
Same Story, Different Night
West Virginia’s defense was shredded again, giving up 517 yards and explosive plays that looked like something out of a highlight reel. Bear Bachmeier passed for 351 yards, the most by a Cougar quarterback in a Big 12 win, while receivers ran free all night. Chase Roberts had 161 yards, Parker Kingston added 111, and BYU made WVU’s secondary look helpless.
Rodriguez didn’t sugarcoat it:
“We made him look like the Heisman winner in the first half.”
And he wasn’t wrong.
Wilkins Asked to Do Too Much
Redshirt freshman Khalil Wilkins wasn’t perfect—he threw two interceptions—but he showed toughness and flashes of potential. He finished with 170 total yards in his first career start, but once again Rodriguez leaned far too heavily on quarterback runs. It’s predictable, it’s ineffective, and it’s putting Wilkins in harm’s way.
The Mountaineers need balance. Right now, they don’t have it.
A Defense With No Answers
Even with Chase Wilson’s interception and Fred Perry’s forced fumble, the defense couldn’t slow BYU. Giving up an 85-yard catch-and-run late in the second quarter summed up the night—bad angles, missed tackles, and a total lack of discipline. That’s not Big 12 football.
The Harsh Truth
West Virginia fans don’t want to hear about “growing pains” forever. The truth is this team looks overmatched and one-dimensional, and Rodriguez’s play-calling hasn’t helped. Yes, the roster is thin. Yes, Wilkins is young. But three weeks into Big 12 play, the Mountaineers have been physically and schematically beaten in every matchup.
Looking Ahead
The future under Rich Rod might be bright, but nights like this show just how steep the climb really is. The Mountaineers don’t have the depth, balance, or discipline to compete right now. That has to change—and fast.
Big 12 opponents should enjoy it while they can, because Rodriguez won’t let this program stay down long. But for now, WVU fans are left with the bitter reality: the Mountaineers are rebuilding, and the Big 12 isn’t waiting around for them to catch up.





