MORGANTOWN, West Virginia — The stage is set in Morgantown for what could be the most electric Backyard Brawl in recent memory, as the Pittsburgh Panthers (2-0) travel to face a reeling West Virginia Mountaineers (1-1). Pitt comes in red hot, having overwhelmed their first two opponents while quarterback Eli Holstein looks sharper than ever. Meanwhile, WVU is desperate for answers, reeling from offensive struggles, key injuries, and an uninspiring effort in their Week 2 loss. Oddsmakers have nodded toward Pitt—making them a roughly seven-point favorite—with projections favoring a high-scoring affair. With rivalry history often producing the unexpected, our staff picks this showdown not just on stats and odds but on grit, momentum, and the kind of game-day energy that makes this rivalry special. Here’s how our experts think today’s game will play out.
Wyatt Coffman, Graphics Designer, The Voice of Morgantown (@wcgraphicdesign): On paper, Pitt is the better team. They have a great defense and elite offensive weapons. This game is critical for the Mountaineers and Rich Rodriguez. Last weekend was undoubtedly one of the most disappointing losses and one of the most uninspired offensive performances by WVU in years. I think it was a fluke. Ohio is a talented team and they simply got the best of us in Athens. I think everyone in our program knows what this game means to the state of West Virginia and the entire fanbase. It goes beyond football. I think WVU starts strong to take the lead in the first half. Pitt will undoubtedly battle in the second half. This will be a very competitive game. In the end, I think the Mountaineer defense will hold strong and the offense will string together enough points to beat the Panthers. Under the bright lights and in front of a sold-out stripe the stadium crowd, West Virginia secures the tremendous victory in the 108th edition of the Backyard Brawl. WVU 24 Pitt 20. Season Record: 1-1
Rush Bishop, Director of Video Content, The Voice of Morgantown (@RushShowVOM): Since 2007, Rich Rodriguez has likely had this game on his mind – and I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s even kept him up at night. Ironically, this year’s matchup falls on 9/13 – a score that Mountaineer fans would rather forget.
I don’t believe coaches intentionally throw games, but I do believe they understand the limitations of their rosters. Sometimes, “scheduled losses” are real. In my opinion, that’s exactly what happened last week against Ohio. Honestly, it didn’t even seem like Rich Rod was all that upset about it.
Looking ahead, if West Virginia is going to win the Backyard Brawl, a few things need to happen:
- Defense must stop the run and force Holstein to beat them. The game could hinge on how the defensive line performs – whether it’s shutting down the run or putting pressure on Holstein in the pocket. Fingers crossed that Jimmori Robinson is part of the game plan.
- The offense must establish the run. With Jahiem out, WVU will have to rely on multiple backs. A solid ground game not only helps move the chains but gives the defense the rest it needs. Assuming Nicco is starting at QB, a strong run game will also give him the time and balance needed to get the ball to his playmakers – especially Cam Vaughn. Nicco needs to make smart decisions. He doesn’t have to swing from the fences on every play – take what the defense gives you.
- Honestly, the concern I felt during the game is now matched by the confidence I feel heading into this game. The final score may not show it, but I believe WVU will control this game – just like they did two years ago. WVU 24 Pitt 13. Season Record: 2-0
Clark Johnson, Senior Football Writer, The Voice of Morgantown: Eat Shit Pitt. WVU 27 pITT 23. Season Record: 1-1
Bernie Mac, Vice President, The Voice of Morgantown (@BernieMac_VOM): WVU is coming off an upsetting loss which also cost them 2 of their star players for the season. I’m very curious to see how the coaches and players respond for what will probably be our biggest home game of the season. WVU is definitely a heavy underdog for this one, especially with Pitt’s aggressive defense and WVU’s struggles on the offensive line, but this is a rivalry game so you never know what can happen. I think WVU’s defense will keep them in it, espeically if Jimmori suits up, but their offense will struggle again. WVU 17 Pitt 28. Season Record: 1-1
Brad Smith, Founder/Publisher, The Voice of Morgantown: Forget what the oddsmakers are saying. Forget Pitt’s early season “momentum.” When the Backyard Brawl kicks off in Morgantown today, it’s going to be a completely different atmosphere — one Pitt hasn’t experienced yet this year.
I expect West Virginia to come out angry, physical, and ready to prove a point. Rich Rodriguez knows exactly what this rivalry means, and his team will feed off the emotion of 60,000 Mountaineer fans who have been circling this date since the schedule was released. WVU’s defense will set the tone early, making life miserable for Eli Holstein, and I fully expect the Mountaineers’ defensive line to dominate the trenches.
On the other side of the ball, Nicco Marchiol will rise to the occasion. He doesn’t need to be perfect — he just needs to make smart throws and let his playmakers go to work. Look for the Mountaineers to finally open up the run game and pound Pitt’s front seven until they wear down. By the second half, I see this one tilting heavily in WVU’s favor.
This won’t be the nail-biter that some are predicting. The Backyard Brawl is staying in Morgantown with authority.
WVU 31 Pitt 17. Season Record: 1-1





