MORGANTOWN, West Virginia — The conversations surrounding Zac Alley’s future as West Virginia’s defensive coordinator are getting louder, and following another embarrassing defensive performance against Arizona, it’s becoming increasingly difficult to imagine the Mountaineers continuing down this same path without some significant changes.

What I’m hearing is that there is growing concern about the direction of West Virginia’s defense and whether Alley is capable of getting things turned around. At this point, there has to be a real, concrete plan for improvement, with measurable expectations and accountability. If that plan can’t be established, or if those responsible don’t believe it can realistically be accomplished, then West Virginia has to seriously consider moving in another direction.

Let’s be clear about something: Being the worst defense in college football is completely unacceptable. It’s unacceptable for Zac Alley, unacceptable for Rich Rodriguez, unacceptable for Wren Baker, and certainly unacceptable for a fan base that has invested so much into this program.

West Virginia is now 3-3 overall and 0-3 in Big 12 Conference play after dropping its third consecutive game, this time a 52-31 embarrassment against Arizona. The Wildcats did essentially whatever they wanted offensively, and it was another example of a defense that simply cannot get off the field, cannot consistently tackle, and cannot prevent explosive plays.

This isn’t an isolated incident, either. Oklahoma State put up 609 yards of offense against the Mountaineers. Iowa State followed with another offensive explosion, and Arizona just added 52 points to the growing list of defensive disasters. Three consecutive conference games, three absolutely dreadful defensive performances, and very little evidence that the problems are being corrected.

The most concerning part of all of this is that we’re seeing the same mistakes week after week. Missed tackles, blown assignments, poor communication, players out of position, and an alarming inability to make adjustments. These aren’t things that should continue happening at this frequency six games into a season.

And while Zac Alley is understandably receiving the majority of the criticism, I don’t believe this situation is entirely his fault.

I’ve said repeatedly that you can have the greatest defensive scheme in college football, but if you don’t have the personnel to execute it, you’re going to struggle. West Virginia made a significant financial commitment to its offensive personnel during the offseason, but did the Mountaineers do enough to address the defensive side of the football?

I don’t believe they did.

There were obvious concerns about the defensive talent and depth entering the season, particularly when it came to finding players capable of making an immediate impact against Big 12 competition. You simply cannot expect to compete for conference championships without investing appropriately on both sides of the ball. That’s a responsibility that extends well beyond the defensive coordinator.

However, there’s also a point where the personnel argument can only go so far.

West Virginia might not have the most talented defense in the Big 12, but there’s absolutely no reason it should be performing at this level. There are programs across the country with fewer resources and less talent that are playing significantly better defense. At some point, coaching, preparation, fundamentals, and player development have to enter the conversation.

That’s where Alley finds himself today.

When Rich Rodriguez brought Alley to Morgantown, the expectation was that he would bring an aggressive, attacking defensive philosophy that complemented Rodriguez’s fast-paced offense. The Mountaineers were supposed to play with a hard edge, create pressure, force turnovers, and make opposing offenses uncomfortable.

Instead, opposing quarterbacks are finding open receivers, running backs are consistently reaching the second level, and offenses are producing explosive plays at an alarming rate.

Where is the hard edge? Where is the physicality? Where is the improvement?

Those are legitimate questions that deserve legitimate answers.

Following the Arizona loss, Rodriguez made it clear just how frustrated he has become with the defense, saying, “I’ve never been so frustrated on one side of the ball as I am with our defense.” He also acknowledged that the Mountaineers haven’t fixed their defensive issues and called the number of big plays they’re allowing ridiculous.

Yet when asked whether he would consider changing defensive play-callers, Rodriguez indicated that such a move was unlikely.

That creates an interesting situation moving forward.

If Rodriguez intends to keep Alley in charge of the defense, then something else has to change. Whether that means simplifying the scheme, adjusting responsibilities among the defensive staff, making personnel changes, or completely reevaluating how the defense prepares each week, there has to be a clear path toward improvement.

And that plan can’t simply consist of promising to tackle better or eliminate mental mistakes. We’ve heard those explanations before. At some point, the results have to change.

The larger concern is what this means for the future of the West Virginia football program.

Rodriguez was brought back to Morgantown to restore a winning culture and eventually put the Mountaineers in position to compete for Big 12 championships. There was tremendous excitement surrounding his return, and for good reason. But that excitement can disappear quickly if the program continues losing games because it cannot stop opposing offenses.

Michael Hawkins Jr. has shown that he can be a difference-maker at quarterback. Cam Cook has demonstrated the type of physical, explosive running ability that fits Rodriguez’s offensive philosophy perfectly. There are legitimate reasons to be encouraged about the direction of the offense.

But none of that matters if West Virginia has to score 40 or 50 points every Saturday just to have a chance to win.

And there’s another factor that shouldn’t be overlooked: recruiting.

Opposing coaching staffs are undoubtedly going to use West Virginia’s defensive struggles against the Mountaineers on the recruiting trail. Players want to develop, compete for championships, and put themselves in position to reach the NFL. When a defense is consistently getting embarrassed on national television, it becomes increasingly difficult to convince elite defensive prospects that Morgantown is the best place for their future.

The longer this continues, the more difficult the rebuilding process becomes.

That’s why I believe the next several days could be extremely important for Rodriguez and the future of his coaching staff.

I’m not suggesting that a decision to fire Alley has already been made. But the conversations surrounding his future are becoming increasingly difficult to ignore, and it’s reasonable to believe that every option should be evaluated.

If Rodriguez ultimately decides that Alley is still the right man for the job, then he needs to establish exactly what improvement is supposed to look like and how quickly it needs to happen.

If he doesn’t believe those improvements are realistic, then delaying the inevitable accomplishes absolutely nothing.

There are also potential replacements worth considering, including former Mountaineer standout Jahmile Addae, who understands the program, has experience coaching at the highest levels of college football, and has established himself as a tremendous recruiter. Whether Addae would be interested or available is another question entirely, but West Virginia should never be afraid to explore its options if a change becomes necessary.

Ultimately, this situation is bigger than Zac Alley.

It’s about the direction of West Virginia football, the expectations surrounding Rich Rodriguez’s return, and whether the Mountaineers are willing to make the difficult decisions necessary to compete at a high level.

I don’t believe anybody expected West Virginia to win a national championship in Rodriguez’s second season back in Morgantown. There was always going to be a rebuilding process, and reasonable fans understood that.

But rebuilding and being completely noncompetitive defensively are two very different things.

You can accept growing pains. You can accept a lack of depth. You can even accept losing games to more talented opponents.

What you cannot accept is watching the same defensive failures happen every single Saturday without meaningful improvement.

What I’m hearing is that the conversations are getting louder. And unless something changes quickly, those conversations could eventually turn into action.

Rich Rodriguez has a decision to make, and it may prove to be one of the most important decisions of his second tenure at West Virginia.

Because at some point, the question is no longer whether Zac Alley deserves more time.

It’s whether West Virginia football can afford to keep waiting.

Share: