PROVO, Utah — West Virginia’s late surge gave them hope, but BYU quickly snatched momentum right back. After the Mountaineers cut the deficit to 21–10 on a Fred Perry forced fumble and Diore Hubbard’s 3-yard touchdown run, the Cougars marched down the field to score again before the half. Now, it’s 28–10, and the Mountaineers face an uphill climb in Provo.

Wilkins Needs More Than His Legs

Redshirt freshman Khalil Wilkins continues to show flashes, but the offense hasn’t done him any favors. He’s been effective enough as a runner, yet the play-calling is far too conservative. Rich Rodriguez must give Wilkins a chance to throw downfield in the second half, or BYU will continue to load the box and punish him on every snap.

Offense is Predictable and Risky

The Mountaineers’ offensive approach remains one-dimensional, and it’s hurting them. Leaning this heavily on Wilkins’ rushing ability isn’t just ineffective—it’s dangerous. He’s taken too many hits already, and if Rodriguez doesn’t diversify the attack, the young QB may not last the full game.

Defense on Its Heels

The defense has had brief flashes, with Chase Wilson’s interception and Perry’s forced fumble standing out. But those moments haven’t been enough to slow BYU’s rhythm. The Cougars are spreading the field, attacking mismatches, and forcing WVU to play catch-up. If the Mountaineers can’t generate more consistent stops, this one could get out of hand quickly.

Big 12 Warning Shot

As frustrating as this half has been, the long-term outlook is different. Big 12 teams should enjoy this now, because Rich Rodriguez is too seasoned to let West Virginia look this flat and predictable for long. This year may be about growing pains, but next year’s Mountaineers won’t be this easy to figure out.

Share: