FORT WORTH, Texas — West Virginia and TCU are tied 10-10 at halftime, and I keep coming back to the same question: How did a team supposedly built on toughness, hard edge and physicality end up looking this soft on defense?
Seriously. How did this happen?
We’ve heard all about the identity Rich Rodriguez wants this program to have. We’ve heard about being tougher than the opponent, playing harder and bringing a physical brand of football back to Morgantown. I want to believe in that. West Virginia fans want to believe in that. But eventually, those words have to show up on the field.
Too often this season, they haven’t.
And yes, I understand that TCU has only scored 10 points through the first half. That’s a manageable number. West Virginia is very much in this game, and the defense deserves credit for keeping the score there. But after everything we’ve watched this season, it’s going to take more than a close halftime score to feel confident about this defense.
When TCU takes the field, do you feel good about West Virginia getting a stop? Do you expect somebody to make a tackle in space? Do you trust this defense when it absolutely has to get off the field?
I wish I could say yes.
That’s what makes watching this team so frustrating. There are reasons to be excited about West Virginia football. Michael Hawkins Jr. is one of them. Cam Cook is another. Imagine how much fun this season could be with those two if we weren’t constantly worried about whether the defense was about to undo everything.
Imagine watching Hawkins take the field knowing he doesn’t have to be spectacular every single week for West Virginia to have a chance. Imagine being able to enjoy a good offensive possession without immediately wondering whether the opponent is about to answer.
That would be a pretty enjoyable football season.
Instead, watching West Virginia feels exhausting. Even with the score tied, it’s hard to relax. We’ve seen too many defensive breakdowns and too many games in which the offense has been asked to carry an unreasonable share of the load. That follows you into the next game. It makes every missed opportunity feel bigger because you don’t know how many stops you’re going to get.
I can’t imagine how frustrating it must be to be Michael Hawkins Jr. right now.
He has given this fan base a reason to keep watching. He has shown what this offense can be capable of. Yet the conversation keeps coming back to how much more West Virginia needs from him. More points. More big plays. Another answer when the other team scores.
How much can you reasonably ask one player to do?
At times, it feels like he’s surrounded by incompetence. That’s harsh, but that’s how frustrating this has become. There are other players working and contributing, including Cook. This isn’t a claim that nobody else cares. It’s frustration with watching a quarterback give you a chance while the team around him keeps struggling to put together a complete performance.
Hawkins is going to make mistakes. He’s going to miss throws. He’s going to have possessions that go nowhere. That happens to quarterbacks everywhere. West Virginia needs to be able to survive those possessions. A punt shouldn’t feel like a disaster waiting to happen.
Now, the offense has responsibilities here, too. Ten points in the first half leaves plenty of room for improvement. West Virginia needs to finish drives and take advantage of its opportunities. You can’t spend the entire afternoon talking about the defense if the offense doesn’t do enough to win a very winnable game.
That’s where Hawkins and Cook have to help lead the way in the second half. There is an opportunity sitting right in front of this team. The score is tied. Whatever frustration we’re carrying from previous weeks, West Virginia has a chance to come out of the locker room and earn a road win.
But the defense has to hold up its end.
I want to see somebody make the tackle that ends a possession. I want to see players in position and playing with confidence. When TCU faces a third down, I want to feel like West Virginia has the advantage for once. Those are reasonable expectations for a Big 12 defense.
And Zac Alley has to find a way to give his players answers they can execute. We’ve spent enough time talking about what hasn’t worked. There is another half of football to play, and whatever adjustments West Virginia makes have to show up immediately.
I still want Rich Rodriguez to get this right. I want the version of West Virginia football he talks about to become the version we actually watch on Saturdays. But I’m tired of hearing about toughness and then watching a defense that too often gets pushed around. Fans are allowed to expect the team’s identity to mean something.
At 10-10, this game is there for the taking. That makes the second half an opportunity, but it also makes another loss that much harder to accept. West Virginia doesn’t need a miracle from here. It needs a better half of football, with contributions from both sides of the ball.
My fear is that we’re about to watch another winnable game slip away and spend the evening talking about the same problems again.
My hope is that somebody in that locker room is tired enough of it to help change the outcome.
Give Hawkins some help. Give Cook a chance to be part of a win. Get the stops this team needs, finish drives and leave Fort Worth with something to build on.
It’s 10-10. Go win the football game.





