MORGANTOWN, West Virginia —Can Rich Rodriguez survive another losing season at West Virginia? It’s a question that seemed almost ridiculous to ask just a couple of weeks ago, but after what we’ve seen recently, I think it’s fair to at least start thinking about it. What happens if West Virginia finishes 4-8 again? What if things really unravel and the Mountaineers go 3-9? Would athletic director Wren Baker actually fire Rich Rodriguez after just two seasons in his return to Morgantown?

My answer right now is no. I think Rodriguez would return in 2027 regardless of how this season finishes. That doesn’t mean his seat wouldn’t become extremely hot. It absolutely would. Another 4-8 season would be a massive disappointment, and a 3-9 finish would be nothing short of a disaster considering the expectations surrounding this program. Baker has made it clear that he expects progress, and nobody brought Rodriguez back to Morgantown to win three or four games a year. But there’s a big difference between being under tremendous pressure and actually being fired, and I just don’t see West Virginia pulling the plug after two seasons.

The biggest reason is pretty simple: two years just isn’t very long. Rodriguez inherited a program that needed to be rebuilt, and while the transfer portal has certainly sped up the rebuilding process in modern college football, turning everything over again after only two seasons would mean starting from scratch all over again. New head coach. New staff. New systems. Another massive roster turnover. Another round of NIL spending. Another attempt to convince players, recruits and donors that this is finally the guy who is going to fix it. I have a hard time believing Baker would want to do all of that again this quickly.

I think Baker would much rather give Rodriguez a third season and essentially tell him that 2027 is the year when this thing has to work. At that point, there are no more excuses. It would be Rodriguez’s roster, Rodriguez’s staff and Rodriguez’s program. If West Virginia still wasn’t showing significant progress after three full seasons, then I think you would be having a very different conversation. But after two? I think Baker would be extremely reluctant to hit the reset button again unless something happened that went far beyond wins and losses.

There’s another factor here that I think is every bit as important, and that’s who is standing behind Rich Rodriguez. Rodriguez has the backing of some of the biggest-money supporters associated with West Virginia athletics, including Pat McAfee and Arizona Diamondbacks owner Ken Kendrick. Those relationships matter. These aren’t people sitting in the upper deck complaining about play-calling. These are people with enormous influence and the ability to financially support the football program at a level very few others can.

Do we really believe those people are going to be ready to give up on Rodriguez after two seasons? I don’t. In fact, I think they would be much more likely to say, “What does Rich need to fix this?” rather than, “How much is it going to cost us to fire him?” That distinction could be extremely important if this season continues heading in the wrong direction.

Now, that doesn’t mean Rodriguez would get to simply bring everybody back and pretend nothing happened. Far from it. If West Virginia finishes 4-8 or 3-9, I think significant changes would almost certainly have to be made. The most obvious place to start would be the defense. If the defensive problems continue for the rest of the season, Rodriguez would have an incredibly difficult decision to make with Zac Alley. I have defended Alley because I believe a major part of West Virginia’s defensive problem is personnel, but at some point the head coach has to make changes when something clearly isn’t working. Alley could ultimately become the fall guy whether the problems are entirely his fault or not.

More importantly, West Virginia would have to change the way it builds the roster. The Mountaineers spent heavily on the offensive side of the football, including putting significant resources into offensive line depth, but they simply did not make the same kind of investment defensively. That cannot happen again. If Rodriguez gets a third year, West Virginia would need to attack the defensive side of the transfer portal with serious money and bring in proven difference-makers, particularly along the defensive line, at linebacker and in the secondary. You can change coordinators all you want, but if you don’t upgrade the personnel, you’re going to keep having many of the same problems.

And that’s why I think the more likely scenario following another bad season isn’t Rich Rodriguez getting fired. It’s Rodriguez being forced to make major changes around him. Maybe that means a new defensive coordinator. Maybe it means changes elsewhere on the staff. It almost certainly means a different approach to roster construction and a much larger investment on the defensive side of the football. Whatever it looks like, Rodriguez would enter 2027 knowing there was no longer any margin for error.

Would the fan base be patient with that? Probably not. If West Virginia goes 3-9 or 4-8, the honeymoon would officially be over. All of the excitement surrounding Rodriguez’s return, the talk about bringing the hard edge back to Morgantown and the belief that he could quickly restore West Virginia football would be replaced by legitimate questions about whether this experiment is actually going to work. That’s the reality of major college football. You don’t get unlimited time anymore, especially when significant money is being spent.

But firing Rodriguez after two seasons would also be an enormous decision with enormous consequences. You would be paying to move on from another coaching staff, paying to hire another one, rebuilding the roster again and asking your biggest donors to financially support yet another reset. When some of those same donors strongly support Rodriguez, that becomes an even tougher sell.

That’s why, even if this season turns into a complete disaster, I believe Rich Rodriguez will be West Virginia’s head football coach in 2027. His seat could be scorching hot. His staff could look very different. The roster could undergo another massive overhaul. The expectations would be enormous, and anything short of significant improvement would probably put his job in serious jeopardy.

But fired after two seasons? I just don’t see it.

If anything, another losing season would probably set up 2027 as the ultimate make-or-break year for Rich Rodriguez at West Virginia. He would get one more offseason to fix the roster, one more opportunity to make whatever staff changes need to be made and one more season to prove that bringing him home was the right decision.

After that, there wouldn’t be many excuses left.

Share: