MORGANTOWN, West Virginia — What if Scotty Fox Jr. gets the start against Houston this Saturday, plays the game of his life, and leads the West Virginia Mountaineers to a massive upset over the nationally ranked Cougars? Seriously, think about that possibility for a moment. What if Fox comes out firing, throws for 250 or 300 yards, makes plays with his legs, and leads West Virginia to its sixth victory of the season, securing bowl eligibility in the process? Would that change the conversation about Michael Hawkins Jr. and who should be West Virginia’s starting quarterback in 2027? Because I think it absolutely would.
Rich Rodriguez revealed Tuesday that Hawkins is questionable for Saturday’s game against Houston after suffering a bone bruise to his ankle during West Virginia’s disappointing 37-14 loss to Kansas. Rodriguez indicated that if Hawkins cannot play, Fox would get the opportunity to start. And here’s where things get interesting. Fox isn’t some inexperienced quarterback who has never played meaningful football for the Mountaineers. In fact, fans should remember exactly what happened the last time he faced Houston. On November 1, 2025, Fox helped lead West Virginia to a stunning 45-35 road victory over the then-No. 22 Cougars. He completed 13 of 22 passes for 157 yards and a touchdown while adding 65 rushing yards and two more touchdowns on the ground. Now imagine him doing it again, this time at Milan Puskar Stadium with bowl eligibility on the line.
The quarterback situation at West Virginia has already been one of the most fascinating storylines surrounding the program’s future. Hawkins has been outstanding statistically in 2026, throwing for 2,128 yards and 13 touchdowns while rushing for 957 yards and an incredible 20 touchdowns. Those numbers deserve recognition. Hawkins has been one of the most productive dual-threat quarterbacks in college football, and there is no denying the impact he has made on West Virginia’s offense. But there’s also a bigger question facing Rodriguez and the Mountaineers. What gives West Virginia the best opportunity to build a competitive football team in 2027? Is it continuing to build around Hawkins, who has demonstrated the ability to produce explosive offensive performances? Or could Fox provide another legitimate option, allowing the coaching staff to evaluate different approaches to constructing next year’s roster?
We don’t know the financial details of any potential player-retention agreements, and there is no verified information establishing what Hawkins or Fox would cost West Virginia in 2027. But roster construction involves difficult decisions regardless of those numbers. The Mountaineers have significant needs on defense, particularly along the defensive line and in the secondary. They also need continued improvement along the offensive line. Every major personnel decision must be considered within that larger picture. And that’s why a strong performance from Fox against Houston could become so important.
If Fox struggles, the conversation probably doesn’t change very much. Hawkins would remain the established starter who has carried much of West Virginia’s offensive production throughout the season. But what happens if Fox looks comfortable, makes excellent decisions, protects the football, and leads the Mountaineers to one of their biggest victories of the year? What happens if the offense looks just as effective, or perhaps even more balanced, with Fox running the show? Suddenly, Rodriguez would have an intriguing decision to make, especially with the offseason approaching.
And let’s be clear about something: This isn’t about disrespecting Hawkins or minimizing what he has accomplished. He’s earned considerable praise for his performance this season, and one game from another quarterback wouldn’t erase that production. But college football is ultimately about winning games and building the strongest possible roster. If Fox gets an opportunity and delivers an outstanding performance against a ranked Houston team, West Virginia would have to take that seriously. It could also make the offseason quarterback competition considerably more interesting than many fans currently expect.
Of course, none of this is guaranteed to happen. Hawkins could recover in time to play Saturday, and Fox may never get the opportunity we’re discussing. But the possibility is fascinating. What if Scotty Fox Jr. starts against Houston, plays outstanding football, and leads West Virginia to bowl eligibility? Would that be enough to make Rich Rodriguez reconsider his quarterback plans for 2027? I don’t think one game should automatically determine the future of the position, but I absolutely believe it could change the conversation. And if Fox gets his opportunity Saturday, Mountaineer Nation will be watching very closely.





